PACT Act Effective Date: What Hepler and Johnson Change
Veterans whose disability claims were granted under the PACT Act may be entitled to earlier effective dates than they were assigned, which could lead to substantially more back pay from the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA).
This is a result of rulings in Hepler v. Collins and Johnson v. Collins, where courts held that a grant under PACT Act presumptions does not resolve a claim for the same condition that was still pending when the law took effect, and that VA must decide that earlier claim.
This article covers what error VA was making, how Hepler and Johnson changed VA policy, and how this may affect veterans whose claims were granted under the PACT Act.
Key points include:
- Many veterans whose claims were granted under the PACT Act were assigned effective dates of August 10, 2022 (i.e., the date the PACT Act took effect), even if they might have been entitled to earlier dates.
- In Hepler and Johnson, courts ruled that VA did not have the authority to close out PACT Act-related claims that were pending when the law took effect.
- Veterans whose claims were still pending or unresolved when the PACT Act took effect may now be entitled to earlier effective dates than Aug. 10, 2022.
Who We Are: Chisholm Chisholm & Kilpatrick (CCK Law) has argued many of the cases that define and clarify veterans disability law. Our attorneys serve in many leadership positions and have posted more than 2,500 blogs and 1,100 videos explaining veterans benefits. With 100+ individuals accredited by VA or admitted to practice before the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims, CCK Law has recovered over $1 billion in compensation for 36,000+ clients since 1999. (Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.) Contact us to tell us about your case.
Watch CCK Law Partner Maura Black discuss incorrect effective dates for claims filed before the PACT Act:

What Mistake Has VA Been Making on PACT Act Claims?
Many pending or unresolved toxic exposure-related disability claims were filed years before the PACT Act took effect on Aug. 10, 2022. After this date, however, VA began using PACT Act presumptions and effective dates to resolve these pending claims, and in the process neglected to address each claim’s original direct service connection pathway.
Specifically, many of these veterans may have been entitled to earlier effective dates had their original claims been addressed. However, by granting these claims under the PACT Act, VA essentially applied a blanket effective date of Aug. 10, 2022.
“VA’s effective date rules generally make benefits pursuant to a liberalizing law, like PACT Act, effective from a date that the law took effect,” says Maura Black, partner at CCK Law. “In other words, a PACT Act grant usually carries an August 10, 2022, effective date.”
This is important because VA back pay is based on a claim’s effective date, which is typically the date VA first received the claim. The earlier a claim’s effective date is, the more back pay the veteran would receive if that claim is eventually granted.
So in other words, by granting and closing out these pending claims under the PACT Act, VA may have inadvertently deprived many of these veterans of their earlier effective dates, and therefore, potentially years of back pay.
As a result, many veterans began to take VA to court to resolve the issue and potentially earn back their initial effective dates and back pay.
How Did Hepler v. Collins Impact PACT Act Effective Dates?
In Hepler v. Collins, the Federal Circuit ruled that VA could not treat the PACT Act grant as resolving Mr. Hepler’s still-pending direct claim for the same condition — the Board must still decide it. Essentially, even if a veteran’s claim is granted under the PACT Act, VA must still address the original direct service connection pathway, since it is still a viable path to entitlement.
In this case, Mr. Hepler was a veteran who served in Vietnam and Kuwait, and who filed a disability claim with VA in 2011 for hypertension. The claim was denied, Mr. Hepler appealed, and over 11 years passed before the Board of Veterans’ Appeals (BVA) decided the claim. By this point, however, the PACT Act had passed, and Mr. Hepler’s claim was granted under PACT Act presumptions.
As a result, however, Mr. Hepler was assigned an effective date of Aug. 10, 2022, for his disability claim, which would deprive him of back pay for the 11 years it took for his claim to resolve. In response, Mr. Hepler appealed to the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (CAVC), which dismissed the appeal as moot.
Finally, Mr. Hepler appealed to the Federal Circuit, and on Aug. 3, 2026, it reversed the CAVC’s earlier decision. As part of its reasoning, the court pointed to Section 407 of the PACT Act’s own text, which reads:
“Nothing in this Act shall be construed to prevent the Secretary of Veterans Affairs from processing claims for benefits…for a condition or disease for which this Act establishes a presumption of service connection, as a claim for benefits for a condition or disease with direct service connection.”
In other words, Congress wrote the law in such a way that the new presumptions specifically do not erase the older path to benefits. Instead, VA must address all viable theories of entitlement, including whether disability benefits could have been granted before the PACT Act made the condition at issue presumptive.
Watch CCK Law Partner Michael Lostritto and VA-Accredited Claims Advocate Dallas Aguiar discuss how effective dates impact back pay:

How Did Johnson v. Collins Affect PACT Act Effective Dates?
In Johnson v. Collins, the CAVC ruled that a regional VA office cannot resolve an appeal that is already pending at the BVA, and that a claim asserting a right that did not exist when the veteran first filed is necessarily a separate and distinct claim.
In this case, Mr. Johnson served as a security guard at Nam Phong Royal Thai Air Force Base in 1973. In May 2016, he filed disability claims for diabetes, peripheral neuropathy, and hypertension related to herbicide exposure he suffered at the base. VA found no exposure and denied his claims, and Mr. Johnson then appealed to the BVA.
However, when the PACT Act took effect, herbicide presumptions were extended to those who served in Thailand during that period. In 2022, Mr. Johnson filed Supplemental Claims under the new law, which a regional office later granted with an effective date of Aug. 10, 2022.
Dissatisfied with this effective date, Mr. Johnson appealed to the BVA once more, this time seeking earlier effective dates for his conditions and arguing that his original appeal to the BVA was still pending. However, the BVA dismissed his older appeal as moot.
In response, Mr. Johnson went on to appeal to the CAVC, and in March 2025, the CAVC reversed the Board’s decision. It reasoned that a claim asserting a right that did not exist when the veteran first filed is necessarily a separate and distinct claim, and that a lower tribunal (i.e., the regional office) cannot decide an issue already on appeal to a higher one (i.e., the BVA).
With this in mind, Mr. Johnson’s initial 2016 claim was remanded back to the BVA for adjudication.
“So, put simply, the existence of a presumption is not the end of the story,” says Maura Black. “If a veteran’s claim predated the presumption and is still open, pending, and unresolved, VA needs to address other viable avenues of service connection prior to the law change in order to maximize the veteran’s benefits.”
What Do These Court Rulings Mean for Veterans?
As a result of the Hepler and Johnson rulings, a veteran whose toxic exposure-related claims were pending or unresolved when the PACT Act took effect may be entitled to an effective date earlier than Aug. 10, 2022.
This is because, under Hepler, a PACT Act presumption taking effect does not eliminate a veteran’s original direct service connection claim, which VA is now required to address. This could result in much earlier effective dates being granted for some veterans.
Similarly, the Johnson ruling drew a distinction between a veteran’s original claim and any subsequent claim they might have filed as a result of changes in the law. To put it simply, if a veteran filed a claim for the same disability both before and after PACT Act regulations took effect, VA must address both of those claims separately. And if the earlier claim is granted, its filing date will determine the effective date for that claim.
With an earlier effective date, veterans could be granted years of retroactive pay for the time it took VA to resolve their claim.
In the video below, CCK Law Partner Bradley Hennings breaks down the five most common PACT Act claims:

Which PACT Act Effective Dates Are Worth a Second Look?
Generally, these court rulings will apply to veterans who had claims that were pending, on appeal, or otherwise unresolved when the PACT Act took effect. Veterans like these may be entitled to effective dates earlier than Aug. 10, 2022, since VA must now address those pending claims in addition to granting them presumptions through the PACT Act.
The table below illustrates who may qualify as a result of these court decisions:
| Veteran’s situation | Effective date VA likely assigned | What the Hepler and Johnson court decisions may add |
| You filed, or submitted an intent to file, a PACT Act claim within one year of its enactment and had no earlier claim. | Aug. 10, 2022 | Nothing. For a grant resting only on a PACT Act presumption, this is the correct floor. |
| You filed a PACT Act claim more than one year after its enactment and had no earlier claim. | The date VA received the claim, or up to one year before it, but never before Aug. 10, 2022 | Nothing. |
| You had a claim for the same toxic exposure-related condition still pending or on appeal when the PACT Act took effect. | Aug. 10, 2022 | VA must still decide that earlier claim. A grant on a pre-PACT Act basis could reach back to the earlier effective date, potentially awarding the veteran additional back pay. |
How Can a Veteran Check a Decision for the Wrong Effective Date?
To check whether VA was in error when it assigned an Aug. 10, 2022, effective date for their claim, veterans should:
- Find the decision letter that granted benefits under the PACT Act and read the effective date assigned to each condition.
- Review the file for a claim for the same condition filed before 10, 2022, and determine whether it was still pending or on appeal when the PACT Act was enacted.
- Check whether VA ever actually resolved that earlier claim on a basis other than the PACT Act presumption. A decision stating only that no other avenue of service connection was warranted, with no discussion of the evidence, may not be an adjudication at all, and could mean the earlier claim is still legally unresolved.
If you feel VA made an error, we recommend you contact a VA-accredited representative for assistance. CCK Law provides free case evaluations.
Think VA May Owe You Additional Back Pay? Contact CCK Law
If you disagree with a VA decision, consider contacting Chisholm Chisholm & Kilpatrick. An experienced, VA-accredited law firm may offer significant tools and resources in support of your appeal.
While past results do not guarantee future outcomes, CCK Law has had favorable outcomes in 98.5% of its actions before VA and a 95% win rate before the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (federal court). We have recovered over $1 billion in compensation for 36,000+ clients to date.
Contact us online or at 800-544-9144 to tell us about your case.
Frequently Asked Questions About PACT Act Effective Dates
Does an earlier effective date change my disability rating?
No. The effective date sets the period for which VA pays, not the percentage it pays at. An earlier date on the same rating produces additional back pay rather than a higher monthly amount.
Do I have to file a new claim to protect an earlier effective date?
Not if the earlier claim is still pending. In that situation, the remedy is a decision from the Board on the claim you already have, not a new filing. Johnson confirms that filing a PACT Act claim does not waive the older one.
What is a liberalizing law?
A liberalizing law is one that makes a substantive change creating a new and different entitlement to a benefit. The PACT Act qualifies because its presumptions removed an element veterans previously had to prove with affirmative evidence.
How long can a Board appeal take to decide?
There is no fixed timeline. In Hepler, more than 11 years passed between the Veteran’s December 2011 filing and the Board’s April 2023 decision, which is why the intervening change in law mattered so much to his back pay.
About the Author
Share this Post