In the Legacy appeals system, a VA Form 9 Substantive Appeal allows you to by ingperfect your case to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals (BVA).  If after receiving your Notice of Disagreement VA continues to deny your claim, you will receive a Statement of the Case (SOC), a procedural document that provides more information about the reasons for the denial. Along with the SOC, it sends VA Form 9, giving you the chance to move forward to the next step in the appeals process.

VA Form 9 provides space for you to explain to the Board why you believe VA made an error in denying your appeal. You may attach documentation to support your assertions, which is recommended for the best chance of a favorable outcome.

Information to Include When Filling Out VA Form 9

VA Form 9 is short and concise. There is only one page to fill out, plus a second page if you need additional space to explain your reasoning, and a third page of instructions and FAQs — which are helpful to read before submitting the form.

The form requests basic information such as your name, claim number, and contact information (home and work phone numbers and address). Next, there is a small space to list the specific issues you have with VA’s decision as described in the Statement of the Case. Below that, there is a much larger space to explain in detail why you believe you were wrongly denied. You can use all of the second page as well, if necessary.

Once you have received your Statement of the Case from VA, it is best to fill out VA Form 9 and submit your appeal to the Board as quickly as possible. As stated in the instructions printed on page 3 of the form, you have only 60 days VA from the date of the Statement of the Case to file your Form 9.

What Happens When VA Receives My VA Form 9

If you fill out VA Form 9 correctly and file it by the deadline with no additional argument or evidence, your appeal will be certified to the Board. You also have the opportunity to request a Board hearingIf you requested a hearing on your Form 9, you will be added to the queue for a hearing. This hearing may take place in person or via video conference. The Board then renders a decision.  If you submit new evidence or argument with your VA Form 9, the regional office will review it and likely issue a Supplemental Statement of the Case prior to your appeal being certified to the Board.

Call Chisholm Chisholm & Kilpatrick LTD Today for a Free Case Evaluation — 800-544-9144

The team of veterans lawyers at Chisholm Chisholm & Kilpatrick LTD may be able to help you appeal to the Board. To speak with a member of our staff today call us at 800-544-9144.


  • It has been one of the best legal experiences that I have personally encountered. Their follow up and their follow thru has been on perfect terms. Wow, they have given me a celebrity experience! Impressive! Read More » K. Nade, October 2017
  • These people are FANTASTIC!!! I highly recommend this firm to Veterans everywhere. Honest Legal Help like this is priceless and they are extremely skilled. So Satisfied with the results...5 stars!! Read More » Anonymous, October 2017
  • I cannot begin to say how grateful I am to this Firm. From the Class A staff to the Lawyers, there are no complaints. Everyone treated me fantastic!! After 30 yrs of fighting on my own, they were able to win my case in less than 15 months. Read More » C. Marie, September 2017
  • My case was initially rejected by the VA but with the thorough review by CC&K , the VA agreed with the case that CC&K made and awarded my initial rating of 30% retroactive to 1975. Read More » Edward M., September 2017
  • We had struggled for eight plus years, with the VA, and got nowhere. Our case was sent to CC&K and in less than one year, we were they won all his back pay and 100% rating. We could not be more pleased. We highly recommend this firm for anyone struggling with the VA. Read More » Anonymous, September 2017
  • I thought I could go it alone. I filed several disability claims through the VA only to be denied over and over again. I knew I needed help. I found that help with the law firm of Chisholm Chisholm & Kilpatrick. They filed for me and won. Read More » Gene W., July 2017
  • I'm so glad we sought the help of CCK on my husband's VA claim. We had been going back and forth with the VA for 5 years on his claim without seeing any progress. Then we found CCK and the case was resolved in about a year! Read More » Sarah C., June 2017
  • I was fighting for my VA disability compensation for 10 years. I was ready to give up and then CCK took my case. I immediately felt at ease because they kept me informed every step of the way and there was so much less stress for me. Read More » Raul B., March 2017
  • Badge
  • Badge
  • Badge
  • Badge
  • Badge
  • Badge
  • Badge