VA Amputation and Loss of Use Ratings
If you suffer from an amputation or loss of use of a part of your body as a result of your military service, you may be entitled to additional VA disability benefits in the form of Special Monthly Compensation (SMC). Specifically, SMC is a monthly benefit for veterans who have service-connected conditions that result in severe impairment, including the loss of use of extremities, blindness, the need for regular aid and attendance, and more. Veterans do not have to apply for this benefit in order to raise the issue before VA. Rather, when reviewing a veteran’s claim for benefits, VA should consider if the veteran is entitled to SMC and grant the benefit if it is warranted. Importantly, SMC rates, except that of SMC (K) which applies in most cases of loss of use, are paid instead of a veteran’s VA disability rating, not in addition to their disability compensation.
Amputation and VA Disability Ratings
VA categorizes amputation in terms of traumatic amputation or amputation by surgical removal. There are different VA disability ratings based on the different types of amputations. For example, VA rates amputations of the arms and hands under 38 CFR § 4.17a (Diagnostic Codes 5120 – 5125) as follows:
- 90% – amputation of entire arm from the shoulder down, either arm
- 90% – amputation below the shoulder but above the elbow for the dominant arm (80% for the non-dominant arm)
- 80% – amputation for below the deltoid but above the elbow for the dominant arm (70% for the non-dominant arm)
- 80% – amputation above the pronator teres for the dominant arm (70% for the non-dominant arm)
- 70% – amputation below the insertion of pronator teres for the dominant arm (60% for the non-dominant arm
- 70% – amputation of the dominant hand (60% for the non-dominant hand
Importantly, for amputation of both arms or hands, VA should award a 100% disability rating.
In terms of amputations of the legs and feet, VA uses the same regulation (i.e. 38 CFR § 4.17a, Schedule of Ratings – Musculoskeletal System) to issue the following ratings:
- 90% – for amputation of the leg at the hip
- 80% – for amputation of the leg at the upper thigh
- 60% – for amputation of the leg at the mid- to lower thigh
- 60% – for cases where a second amputation has been required due to complications from the first amputation
- 60% – for amputations that render the knee joint unstable
- 40% – for amputation of the leg below the knee
- 40% – for amputation that renders the foot or ankle unusable
- 10 – 40% – various rankings for different levels of foot amputations
Again, if amputation of both legs or feet is present, VA should award a 100% disability rating. It is also important to note that VA does not make a distinction between the dominant and non-dominant extremities when rating amputations of the legs and feet.
Temporary Total Ratings Due to Convalescence
If a veteran’s amputation requires extensive periods of hospitalization or convalescence, it can be rated at 100% disabling for a certain period of time. This time period usually lasts for 3 months, at which time VA will re-evaluate based on the rating criteria listed above.
Loss of Use
According to VA, loss of use is held to exist when a part of the body would function equally as well as an amputation with use of a suitable prosthesis. Importantly, amputation is not required in order to experience loss of use. Determinations of loss of use are made on the basis of the actual remaining function of the upper or lower extremities (e.g. hand or foot). In regards to determining loss of use of one or both hands, VA considers a veteran’s ability to carry out acts of grasping, manipulation, etc. In terms of loss of use of one or both feet, VA considers acts of balance, propulsion, etc. Loss of use does not need to be the result of any one particular injury or illness. While loss of use of the hands and feet are very common for VA rating purposes and SMC benefits, loss of use can also be applied to the following:
- An immobilized joint or paralyzed limb
- Loss of use of a reproductive organ
- Loss of sight in one eye
- Deafness in both ears
- Inability to communicate by speech
- Loss of a breast, or both breasts, from mastectomy or radiation treatment
- Denial of extraschedular referral for bilateral hearing loss disability rested on provision of inadequate reasons or bases
- Denial of service connection for hearing loss disability failed to consider delayed onset
- Caregiver Program: Veterans risk loss of care due to inability to appeal VHA decisions
- Board applies wrong standard for SMC based on loss of use
- Hearing loss denial contained legal error by Board
- How Many Vietnam Veterans Have Been Affected by Agent Orange?
- Is RAMP a Part of the Veterans Appeals Improvement and Modernization Act of 2017?
- What is the CAVC, or Veterans Court?
- How Do You Determine the Effective Date of Veterans Disability?
- Are Veterans Disability Benefits Taxable?
- The Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (CAVC)
- BREAKING NEWS: Court Rules Blue Water Navy Veterans Should Be Eligible for Agent Orange Presumption
- Top 3 Benefits Issues for the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) in 2019
- Thailand Veterans Exposed to Agent Orange Deserve Compensation
- Blue Water Navy Veterans Update – June 2019