Board erred in denying PGW Vet separate disability ratings
The Veteran was rated at 40-percent for symptoms arising from his service in Saudi Arabia. These symptoms included chest pain, joint pain, muscle aches, fatigue, sleep disturbance, headaches, and irritable bowel symptoms. His symptoms were regarded as an undiagnosed illness and rated by analogy to fibromyalgia under diagnostic code 5025. CCK argued that the Board erred in denying separate disability ratings for IBS and headaches. CCK also argued that the Board erred when it failed to consider separate disability ratings for each painful joint.
The Court held that the Board erred in denying separate disability ratings for IBS and headaches under 38 C.F.R. § 4.114, DC 7319 and 38 C.F.R. § 4.124a, DC 8100, respectively. It also held that the Board failed to consider separate disability ratings for each of his painful joints under 38 C.F.R. § 4.59.
Regarding IBS, the Board did not explain why the Veteran’s bowel symptoms were not ratable by analogy to another diagnostic code associated with the digestive system. The Board failed to consider a VA examiner’s opinion that the Veteran’s medication indicated he suffered from headaches severe enough to cause him to stop work. Regarding each of the Veteran’s painful joints, the Court noted that the Board made no credibility finding with respect to lay statements of joint pain observed by the Veteran’s coworkers and wife. Thus, the Court determined it must treat the lay statements as both competent and probative. Therefore, the Board was required to consider rating the Veteran’s joint pain per each separate joint. The Court set aside the Board’s decision and remanded for further proceedings.
To read the Court’s decision, click here.
- Board Misinterprets Applicable Laws in Denying an Increased Rating and Temporary Total for GERD
- Board relied on inadequate examinations in denying service-connection for thoracolumbar degenerative disc disease
- Board erred in relying on inadequate medical opinion for shoulder disability
- Board Erred in Relying on Inadequate Exam for Gout
- Board Erred in Denying Gulf War Vet Service Connection for Insomnia Disorder Based on Pyramiding
- Can VA Take Away Your Disability Rating?
- Getting Veterans (VA) Disability for Toxic Water at Camp Lejeune
- How Exactly Does RAMP Work for Veterans’ Disability Appeals?
- What Are Some Common Disability Coverage Limitations?
- How Will I Pay for My ERISA Disability Lawyer?
- 100% VA Disability and Working
- VA Disability For Depression & Anxiety
- Burn Pits and VA Disability Benefits
- 7 Common Long-Term Disability Claim Mistakes
- Long-Term Disability and Vocational Evidence
- Service-Connected Disability Definition
- Extraschedular VA Ratings Definition
- Staged Ratings Definition
Share this Post